SC seeks ECI's response to Rahul Gandhi's plea for 48 questions on SIR
The Supreme Court on Tuesday, November 17, sought the Election Commission of India's (ECI) response to an application filed by Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA Bloc leaders seeking permission to put 48 formal written questions, known as interrogatories, to the poll body over its decision-making during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
The petitioners want the Election Commission to disclose records and provide details about how key decisions concerning the nationwide revision were taken, including whether Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had unanimously approved the decisions.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana heard the matter. Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for Rahul Gandhi, told the court that the application had been filed on Monday. He argued that the ECI's counter-affidavit, submitted on October 26, relied on claims of unanimous decisions and approvals without providing the relevant dates, file notings, records or details of the decision-making process.
Senior Advocate Harish Salve, representing the ECI, said the Commission had serious reservations about the application. The bench directed the poll body to file its objections and scheduled the matter for December 9. It said it would hear the petitioners on their request to serve the interrogatories before deciding whether to permit them.
Questions over approval of ECI's affidavit
One of the principal issues raised in the application concerns the counter-affidavit filed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The ECI had stated that the affidavit was approved for submission before the Supreme Court through a unanimous decision of all three members of the Commission.
The petitioners want Yeturu to clarify whether the affidavit was approved by Gyanesh Kumar, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. They have also sought details of whether the approval was given at a meeting, through circulation of a file or by electronic communication.
The application seeks the dates on which each Commissioner approved the affidavit, along with the relevant records documenting their consent. It also asks whether any of the three members suggested changes, raised objections or expressed reservations before it was filed.
The opposition leaders have further questioned whether the Commission's decisions on the SIR, the ECINET platform, Form 6 and the filing of appeals were taken unanimously or by majority. They want the Election Commissioners to disclose the number of occasions between February 19, 2025, and October 26, 2026, on which they recorded written objections, dissents or reservations concerning these matters.
Interrogatories seek records of SIR decisions
The 48 questions also examine the ECI's claim that its orders dated June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026, were issued following unanimous decisions of the Commission.
The petitioners have sought the file numbers, dates and records associated with each decision. They want to know whether the approvals were granted during formal meetings, through circulation of files or by electronic means, and when each Commissioner conveyed their approval.
A separate set of questions concerns the June 24, 2025, order, which stated that the Commission had decided to begin the SIR across the country.
The opposition leaders have pointed to an apparent discrepancy between the ECI's affidavit and an order issued by its First Appellate Authority under the Right to Information Act. According to the petitioners, the appellate authority had stated that the Commission had not taken a decision to initiate a nationwide SIR in 2025.
They have asked the ECI to explain this difference and clarify whether the relevant decision file existed when the Central Public Information Officer, on August 27, 2025, said that information about such a decision was unavailable.
The application also seeks to establish whether the Election Commissioners were involved in decisions concerning the nationwide exercise or whether the Chief Election Commissioner acted without the knowledge, approval or concurrence of the other two members.
Form 6 declaration and voter exclusions
Another group of interrogatories concerns the additional declaration introduced on the online Form 6 application page during the SIR.
The petitioners want to know who authorised the addition, when it was introduced and whether the decision received the Commission's approval. They have also asked whether any Election Commissioner objected to the declaration.
They have sought figures for Form 6 applications that were submitted, rejected, kept pending or left unprocessed because of the additional declaration or mapping-related requirements.
The application further seeks state-wise and Union Territory-wise data on electors whose names were excluded from draft or final electoral rolls. The petitioners want the ECI to provide the reasons for each category of exclusion, including death, shifting, absence, duplication and ineligibility.
Questions have also been raised about objections filed through Form 7. The opposition leaders have sought details of the number of objections submitted by individual applicants and Booth Level Agents, including cases involving false or non-existent persons. They have also asked what action was taken under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act in such cases.
The petitioners have additionally sought information on whether any electoral-roll entry was added, deleted or modified without an order from an Electoral Registration Officer (ERO). This includes changes allegedly carried out through bulk operations, system-level interventions, de-duplication or data migration.
Questions on ECINET access and West Bengal appeals
The functioning of ECINET, the ECI's digital platform, is another major area covered by the application.
The petitioners have asked whether EROs were provided with a facility to restore an electoral-roll entry after it had been omitted or deleted during the SIR conducted under the orders of October 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026. If the facility was unavailable at any point, they want the ECI to specify the period during which it could not be used and the date on which it became available.
They have also sought details of a proposal by Election Commissioner Vivek Joshi for an audit of individuals who had access to, and the ability to modify, the electoral-roll database. The ECI has been asked whether the proposal was placed before the Commission and, if so, to disclose the date, file number and decision taken on it.
The interrogatories also seek the total number of appeals filed before Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal, either by the Commission or in the name of its officers, against inclusion orders passed by judicial officers. The petitioners want details of the period during which these appeals were filed.
The application also seeks clarity on the access of private contractors and vendors to the electoral-roll database, including whether they had permission to make changes. It raises questions about alleged bulk deletions without individual ERO orders and seeks details of any urgent approvals communicated through platforms such as WhatsApp or personal email.
The petitioners have also asked that if the ECI claims privilege over any official record, it should specify the grounds for withholding each document so that the court can examine the claim.
Opposition leaders challenge ECI's decision-making
The application is part of a wider legal challenge to the ECI's functioning and its conduct of the SIR. On October 15, the Supreme Court issued notice on a petition filed by Gandhi and other opposition leaders questioning the Commission's decision-making process and seeking disclosure of records relating to the nationwide revision.
Apart from Rahul Gandhi and Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, the petitioners include Saugata Roy of the Trinamool Congress, Akhilesh Yadav of the Samajwadi Party, Tejashwi Prasad Yadav of the Rashtriya Janata Dal, Sanjay Raut of Shiv Sena (UBT), MA Baby of the CPI(M), D Raja of the CPI, Mahua Majhi of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha, Supriya Sule of the NCP (Sharad Pawar faction) and ET Muhammed Basheer of the IUML.
VCK president Thol. Thirumavalavan and National Conference MP Sajjat Ahmad Kichloo subsequently joined the petition, taking the total number of opposition leaders involved to 13.
The application seeks permission to serve the interrogatories on the ECI and obtain answers from the officials concerned through affidavits. The petitioners have relied on the Supreme Court's Constitution Bench judgment in the Justice KS Puttaswamy (Retd.) case, arguing that the court can require officials to answer specific questions when facts central to a constitutional challenge are within the exclusive knowledge of an authority administering a technological system.
ECI maintains SIR orders were unanimously approved
In its counter-affidavit filed on October 26, the Election Commission maintained that the three orders concerning the SIR, dated June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026, had been unanimously approved by all three members.
The poll body denied that the Chief Election Commissioner had taken unilateral decisions regarding the exercise. It also maintained that the additional declaration introduced during the SIR did not amount to an amendment of the statutory Form 6.
The ECI subsequently filed a supplementary affidavit on November 14, both affidavits being affirmed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The opposition leaders have argued that the responses still do not provide the underlying records needed to verify the Commission's claims.
The latest application has been filed through Advocate-on-Record Prasanna S. The Supreme Court will consider the ECI's objections and the petitioners' request for permission to serve the 48 interrogatories when the matter comes up on December 9.
.png)
