'Sad day for democracy' if criminal cases are used to silence protests, says Bombay HC
The Bombay High Court has warned against using criminal prosecution to suppress peaceful protests, observing that such a practice would be a "sad day for democracy". The court made the observation while quashing an FIR against a man accused of participating in a protest over the poor condition of a road in Maharashtra's Chandrapur district, where a vehicle had overturned, claiming the life of a passenger.
A single-judge bench of Justice Mahendra Chandwani at the Nagpur bench noted that the applicant, Nishkarsh Nimgade, was among those who had allegedly gathered to demand the removal of Public Works Department (PWD) officials responsible for constructing the substandard road.
The court stressed that peaceful demonstrations against administrative failures are protected under the Constitution and cannot become grounds for criminal action unless the protesters resort to violence or damage public or private property.
'Sad day for democracy' if protests face criminal action
Highlighting the constitutional protection available to peaceful demonstrations, the court referred to Article 19(1)(b), which guarantees citizens the right to assemble peacefully and without arms.
"Article 19(1)(b) of the Constitution guarantees the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. While reasonable restrictions could always be imposed on exercising this fundamental right, such right must not be diluted or stifled based upon vague charges bereft of the essential ingredients to constitute offences under the penal laws. The lines between the constitutional right to protest and the unleashing of penal prosecutions cannot be allowed to be blurred. If this mindset gains traction, it would be a sad day for democracy," the judge observed.
The judge added that the right to protest cannot be curtailed through criminal proceedings when the allegations do not establish the necessary ingredients of an offence.
Court finds no evidence of road obstruction
In its October 29 order, the court also examined the chargesheet and found no evidence to establish that the protesters had obstructed anyone's movement by tying a rope across the road.
The judge pointed out that investigators had not recorded a single statement from a passerby who was allegedly prevented from using the road.
"Not a single statement of any passerby is recorded whose right of way had been obstructed by the people who gathered on the spot. Therefore, the ingredients of Section 126 of the BNS are not attracted against the applicant."
The court further observed that merely gathering in large numbers to demand action against errant PWD officials and the contractor did not automatically amount to forming an unlawful assembly under Section 189 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).
It held that the prosecution could not establish an illegal object behind the gathering, a necessary requirement for treating it as an unlawful assembly.
.png)
