'Neither practicable nor wise': Why CJI Surya Kant is against banning AI
Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant has said that banning generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools would be neither practical nor sensible, arguing that institutions should focus on regulating their use rather than imposing a blanket prohibition. He said AI was already influencing legal education, research and professional work, making it important to ensure that students and legal practitioners used the technology responsibly.
Addressing the first annual international conference of the Commonwealth Legal Education Association (CLEA) in Hyderabad on Saturday, the CJI cautioned against allowing AI-generated content to replace independent thinking and legal understanding.
“The question, therefore, is no longer whether students will use these tools, but whether the work they submit still reflects their own reasoning, understanding, and appreciation for the law,” he said.
CJI bats for responsible use of AI in legal education
Justice Kant said prohibiting AI tools could push students towards using them without institutional oversight. Instead, law schools should establish clear guidelines and teach students how to use such technology without compromising academic integrity.
Citing the approach of courts across the Commonwealth, he referred to the Supreme Court of Singapore, which allows court users to use generative AI while holding them responsible for the material they submit.
“The wiser course is to set clear rules and to teach responsible use, so that technology assists the student’s search,” he said.
The CJI also flagged the risks of relying on AI for legal research, pointing out that seemingly convincing responses could contain fabricated judicial references, miss important qualifications in judgments or offer incomplete legal comparisons.
“An AI system cannot be credited as an author, precisely because it cannot be held responsible for the work,” he said.
He stressed that researchers must cross-check legal references with original sources, disclose significant AI assistance and take responsibility for published work. He also warned against uploading confidential manuscripts, research material and client information to external AI platforms without considering privacy, consent and security.
Legal education must go beyond textbooks
Moving beyond AI, Justice Kant called for a stronger practical component in legal education, saying students must learn to apply legal principles to actual disputes rather than rely solely on theoretical instruction.
He suggested incorporating practical exercises into core subjects, including constitutional law, evidence, criminal procedure and family law. Students studying contract law, for instance, could be asked to draft and negotiate agreements.
He also proposed making a minimum period of legal aid work compulsory for all law students before graduation, with additional academic credits for those undertaking work beyond the prescribed requirement.
The CJI said legal learning must continue beyond enrolment as an advocate, emphasising the need for institutions that connect classroom education with the realities of justice delivery.
.png)
