INDIA bloc questions ECI's claim of unanimous decisions, seeks permission to interrogate officials | File Image
INDIA bloc questions ECI's claim of unanimous decisions, seeks permission to interrogate officials | File Image

INDIA bloc seeks Supreme Court nod to question ECI officials over 48 SIR-related queries

48 questions target ECI's SIR process, internal disagreements and access to voter databases

Opposition parties have approached the Supreme Court seeking permission to formally question Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, the two Election Commissioners and other senior officials over the Election Commission of India's (ECI) handling of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.

In an application filed on Monday, the INDIA bloc petitioners submitted 48 questions, seeking detailed responses supported by official records. They alleged that the ECI's counter-affidavit in the ongoing proceedings contained assertions but did not provide the relevant facts and documents needed to address their concerns.

The petitioners argued that the proposed interrogatories were necessary to establish how key decisions concerning the SIR were taken, who authorised them and whether they had the approval of the Commission as a collective body. They maintained that the information sought was exclusively in the ECI's possession and that their questions were intended to verify the poll body's claims, rather than initiate a fishing enquiry.

The questions have been directed at Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and other officials, including Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu. The latest reports on the application also identify the Director General of the ECI's Information Technology division among the officials the Opposition wants to question.

Explaining why the answers were necessary, the petitioners said they wanted to establish whether decisions were taken by the Commission as a body, when and how they were made, who authorised actions in its name, and how the ECINET platform was designed, modified and operated.

Opposition questions decision to conduct nationwide SIR

One of the central issues raised in the application is the decision to launch a nationwide SIR in 2025. The Opposition wants the ECI to disclose when the decision was taken, the process through which it was approved and whether there were differences among the three members of the Commission.

The petitioners have also pointed to an apparent contradiction between the ECI's 2025 order announcing a nationwide SIR and a subsequent response to a Right to Information (RTI) application, which reportedly stated that the Commission had no information available on such a decision.

They have asked the poll body to provide the file number associated with each SIR order, the date on which the decision was taken and whether it was approved at a meeting, through circulation of a file or by electronic means. They have also sought the dates on which each Election Commissioner signified approval.

The application further seeks details of the three major SIR orders issued on June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026. The ECI has maintained in its counter-affidavit that all three decisions were taken unanimously by the Commission.

The Opposition has questioned that assertion and wants the official records, including file notings and electronic communications, to establish how the decisions were reached.

48 questions seek details of alleged differences within ECI

The petitioners have specifically sought information about any objections or disagreements recorded by Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi on matters concerning the SIR, ECINET, Form 6 and the filing of appeals.

They have asked the Commission to state how many times the two commissioners recorded a written objection, dissent or reservation between February 19, 2025, and October 26, 2026. For each instance, they want the date, file number and subject matter disclosed.

The application also asks whether any SIR-related decision was taken by a majority under Section 18(2) of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023. If so, the petitioners want details of each such decision and the identity of the dissenting member.

The questions come amid reports of differences within the Commission over aspects of the SIR exercise. The ECI has defended its decision-making process, maintaining that the three major orders were unanimously approved.

The Opposition has also sought details of how approvals were obtained in urgent situations, including whether official or personal emails, WhatsApp, other messaging applications or the e-Office system were used. It wants the number of decisions cleared through these channels and confirmation of whether the relevant communications, logs and metadata have been preserved.

ECINET, voter database access and audit trails under scrutiny

Another major area of concern is the control and operation of ECINET and ERONET, the digital platforms associated with electoral roll management.

The petitioners have sought details of the authorities responsible for operating ECINET, along with records of decisions approving its design, architecture and deployment. They have also raised questions about who has access to electoral roll databases and who is authorised to add, delete, modify or restore voter entries.

In particular, they want to know whether employees of private vendors or contractors have been given privileged access or the ability to make changes to voter records.

The application seeks details of any alterations made to electoral roll entries without an order from an Electoral Registration Officer (ERO), including through bulk operations, system-level changes, de-duplication or data migration.

The Opposition has also sought information on the audit trails maintained by ECINET. It wants the ECI to clarify whether every change to a voter's record is logged with the user account responsible, the date and time of the alteration, and the corresponding ERO order.

The petitioners have further asked whether the audit records have been preserved and whether electoral registration officers have the facility to restore entries that were omitted or deleted during the SIR. They have also sought details of a proposal by Election Commissioner Vivek Joshi to audit individuals who had access to and the ability to alter the electoral roll database.

Questions raised over Form 6 changes and voter exclusions

The online Form 6 process, used by individuals seeking inclusion in electoral rolls, is another focus of the interrogatories.

The petitioners have sought an explanation for the introduction of an additional declaration in the online form, including when the change was made, which officer or division authorised it and whether the Commission subsequently approved it.

They have also asked how many Form 6 applications were rejected, left pending or not processed because applicants did not submit the additional declaration or the required mapping details.

The questions seek details of the October 21 decision of the Electoral Registration Division and whether it was placed before the full Commission or received its approval.

The ECI has maintained that Form 6 itself was not amended and that the additional declaration was a separate document. The Opposition is seeking the underlying records to examine that explanation.

The application also seeks state-wise figures for voters excluded at different stages of the revision, including the pre-SIR, draft and final electoral rolls. The petitioners want a break-up of the reasons for exclusion, including deaths, migration, absence, duplication and ineligibility.

They have also sought information about the 97 electors in Goa referred to in the ECI's counter-affidavit. The questions include how many of the 88 electors who reportedly submitted Form 6 applications had their original entries restored and how many were enrolled afresh.

West Bengal appeals and judicial officers' orders questioned

The INDIA bloc has also raised questions about appeals filed against orders passed by judicial officers in West Bengal allowing voters to be included in electoral rolls.

The petitioners want the ECI to disclose the total number of such appeals, the officials who authorised them and the criteria used to decide which cases should be challenged. They have also sought details of the current status of these appeals.

The Opposition's questions extend to the broader process through which electoral roll entries were modified, restored or excluded during the revision exercise.

Supreme Court hearing scheduled for November 17

The application forms part of the INDIA bloc's wider legal challenge to the functioning of the Election Commission and the conduct of the SIR exercise.

The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear the batch of petitions on Tuesday, November 17. At the previous hearing on October 27, a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant, along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, granted the petitioners 10 days to respond to the ECI's counter-affidavit.

During that hearing, the Opposition had sought preservation of the Commission's files, internal notings and communications, arguing that these records were necessary to establish whether key decisions had been taken unanimously. The court did not expressly issue a direction to preserve the records but said it would examine the allegations.

The bench had also issued notice on a separate petition filed by Rajya Sabha MP Dola Sen, which raised concerns about alleged changes to Form 6 during the Bihar SIR.

The ECI, in its counter-affidavit, rejected allegations of unilateral decision-making and maintained that all three major decisions concerning the SIR had been approved unanimously. The INDIA bloc now wants the Supreme Court to allow its 48 interrogatories so that the Commission's claims can be tested against official records.

Responsive Banner