Panihati BJP MLA says her political stance remains unchanged after controversial remark | File Image 
West Bengal

Ratna Debnath clarifies ‘BJP not winning would have been better’ remark after worker’s death

BJP MLA clarifies remarks after breaking down while consoling family of deceased party worker

Panihati BJP MLA Ratna Debnath has sought to clarify her emotional remark that “it would have been better if the BJP had not won” after the death of a party worker in the area triggered a political controversy. Facing criticism over the statement, Debnath issued a written clarification on Monday, insisting that her words had been taken out of context and did not reflect any change in her political position.

The MLA maintained that she had neither intended to undermine the ruling party nor suggested that the BJP coming to power in West Bengal was a mistake. She said a portion of her remarks had been presented without the surrounding context, resulting in a misleading interpretation.

Debnath also reiterated her faith in Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari, state BJP president Samik Bhattacharya and the party’s senior leadership. She made it clear that her political position remained unchanged and that she continued to stand with the BJP.

MLA's emotional remark sparks controversy

The controversy erupted after Debnath visited the family of a BJP worker who died following an alleged assault in Panihati. Overcome with emotion while consoling the grieving family, the MLA broke down and said, “It would have been better if the BJP had not won.”

Her remarks triggered a political storm, with the statement also causing discomfort within the BJP. The subsequent clarification was aimed at explaining the circumstances in which she had made the comment and reaffirming her allegiance to the party.

How the BJP worker died

The controversy followed the death of Arup Saha, whose wife Ruma Saha is the BJP secretary of Panihati-1 mandal. On Saturday night, Ruma was returning home when she allegedly witnessed an altercation involving a local businessman in a market area.

She initially attempted to intervene and stop the dispute. After reaching home, she informed her husband about what had happened. Arup then rushed to the spot in an attempt to resolve the matter.

However, he was allegedly pushed forcefully in the chest during the confrontation, causing him to fall to the ground. After returning home later that night, he began feeling unwell. He was immediately taken to Sagar Dutta Hospital for treatment, but doctors declared him dead.

News of his death left the local BJP leadership shaken. Debnath, who visited the bereaved family to offer her condolences, broke down in tears, leading to the controversial remark that subsequently triggered a political row.