Justice Nagarathna seeks 33 per cent quota for women lawyers | X 
Legal

'Women in high offices does not mean equality': SC judge BV Nagarathna

Supreme Court judge has said women's presence in top public offices does not reflect true gender equality, calling for action against structural barriers in education, employment & legal profession

The presence of women in top constitutional and public positions cannot be treated as proof that gender equality has been achieved in India, Supreme Court judge BV Nagarathna has said, highlighting the structural challenges that continue to limit women's access to education, employment and professional growth.

Speaking at the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Somerville College, University of Oxford, earlier this week, Justice Nagarathna stressed that the experiences of a few successful women cannot represent the realities faced by millions across the country. She said achieving substantive equality required addressing barriers within society and institutions.

“I have had the benefit of education and a career to pursue but there are many women in India who find it difficult to pursue education or have a career, even though well qualified. Indian society, particularly the male society needs to introspect on this critical aspect, if the cherished goals of our Constitution are to be achieved by the women of India,” she said.

Justice Nagarathna seeks greater representation in legal profession

The Supreme Court judge also called for one-third representation for women lawyers on government panels, including those representing public sector undertakings and providing legal aid.

She said equal participation in the justice system should extend beyond allowing women to enter the profession and include opportunities to represent government bodies and hold positions of authority.

“If women are to participate equally in the administration of justice, their representation must extend beyond the right to enter the profession. It must encompass opportunities to represent the State, advise public institutions, and participate in the exercise of legal authority,” she said.

Justice Nagarathna is expected to become India's first woman Chief Justice in September 2027. However, the representation of women in the higher judiciary remains limited. There are currently three women among the Supreme Court's 37 sitting judges, while women account for 111 of the 781 sitting judges across the country's 25 high courts.

Equality must address social and economic barriers

Tracing the development of women's rights in India, Justice Nagarathna referred to landmark judicial interventions, including the 2005 ruling recognising daughters as equal coparceners in ancestral property, the Vishaka guidelines against workplace sexual harassment and judgments addressing gender discrimination in employment.

She also highlighted the disproportionate burden of unpaid domestic and care work, saying women's opportunities were shaped by social and economic circumstances.

“Equality must be attentive to differences among women. There is no single experience of being a woman,” she said, pointing to the influence of caste, class, disability, religion and region.

Emphasising that women's empowerment required equal opportunities both at home and outside, she said, “The women of India are asking for their basic and constitutional rights which have to be provided both at home and outside.”

She added, “If the women are able to fulfil their choices and goals, I feel that the word ‘empowerment’ would pale into insignificance,” she said.