The Supreme Court has ruled that an accidental gunshot injury suffered by an Army personnel from his own service weapon while on operational duty can be classified as a Battle Casualty, making him eligible for the enhanced War Injury Element of pension.
The Court clarified that an injury cannot be treated as self-inflicted merely because the bullet was fired from the serviceman’s own weapon. The exclusion applicable to self-inflicted injuries does not extend to every accidental injury involving a soldier’s service gun.
A bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed an appeal filed by retired Army Subedar Major and Honorary Lieutenant Devi Singh, setting aside the Armed Forces Tribunal’s decision denying him the enhanced pensionary benefit.
Injury during Operation Rakshak
Singh sustained a gunshot wound on August 7, 2002, while on duty in Jammu and Kashmir during Operation Rakshak and Operation Parakram. His loaded weapon accidentally discharged, with the bullet passing through his left thigh and damaging his femoral vein.
The Release Medical Board assessed his disability at 40% for life and held that it was attributable to military service. However, the Army granted him only the ordinary Disability Element of pension.
His claim for the enhanced War Injury Element was rejected by the Armed Forces Tribunal on the grounds that the competent authority, MP-5, had not issued final Battle Casualty approval and his name was absent from the relevant digital database.
Army records established Battle Casualty status
Setting aside the Tribunal’s decision, the judgment authored by Justice Kotiswar Singh relied on Part II Order No. BC-59, which recorded the incident contemporaneously under the heading ‘Battle Casualty Wound OP Rakshak OP Parakram’.
The Court also considered the Battle Casualty Certificate issued by Signals Records and the medical authorities’ finding that the injury was grievous.
Paragraph 69 of Army Order 1/2003/MP lays down two conditions for classifying an injury as a Battle Casualty. The injury must have occurred in the prescribed operational circumstances and must be at least grievous in nature.
The bench held that both requirements were fulfilled in Singh’s case.
Accidental discharge is not necessarily self-inflicted
“The source of the bullet cannot, by itself, determine whether the wound was self-inflicted,” the Court observed.
It explained that a service weapon could discharge accidentally due to an impact, a fall, the trigger getting snagged, inadvertent pressure on the trigger or a mechanical defect. Such incidents, the Court said, are distinct from deliberately self-inflicted injuries.
The judgment noted that the earliest surviving official record described the discharge as accidental. No Court of Inquiry finding, disciplinary order, medical opinion or command decision had classified the injury as deliberate or self-inflicted.
The Court further observed that an officially recorded accident could not be converted into a self-inflicted injury merely because the weapon belonged to the appellant, in the absence of contrary contemporaneous material.
Missing records and digital database entry
The Union had relied on the absence of original Army records. The Court rejected this argument, noting that the documents had been destroyed in the 2014 floods while in official custody.
It also held that the absence of Singh’s name from a subsequently created digital database could not disprove the contemporaneous and signed official records that had survived.
“The absence of the appellant's name from a subsequently created digital database is merely the absence of further corroboration, but it is not affirmative evidence capable of disproving the contemporaneous and signed official records that have survived,” the Court said.
The bench added that the appellant could not be made to suffer for circumstances beyond his control.
War Injury Element to be paid within three months
The Supreme Court directed the Union Government to sanction and pay Singh the War Injury Element from his date of retirement, in accordance with Regulation 103 of the Pension Regulations for the Army.
The Disability Element already paid for the same disability and period must be adjusted to prevent duplication. The revised Pension Payment Order and net arrears are to be issued and paid within three months.
The Court accordingly set aside the Armed Forces Tribunal’s judgment dated May 10, 2023, and its subsequent order dated July 19, 2023.
The case was titled JC-377745M Ex Sub Maj & Hony Lt Devi Singh v. Union of India & Ors. The judgment was delivered on November 20, 2026, in Civil Appeal No. 14606 of 2026.