Supreme Court to hear competing rights of protesters, traders and residents near Ramlila Maidan | File Image 
Legal

SC seeks Congress, AAP, CJP, AISA replies to traders' plea against Ramlila Maidan protests

Traders challenge Ramlila Maidan's designation as a protest site, citing business losses

The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought responses from the Congress, Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) and All India Students Union (AISA) on a petition by Delhi traders challenging the designation of Ramlila Maidan as a venue for protests, citing disruption to commercial activity and losses to livelihoods.

A bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, also comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, issued notices to the organisations, the Centre, the Delhi government and the Delhi Police Commissioner. The matter will be heard again on November 27, along with other petitions concerning the right to protest and restrictions imposed by authorities in Delhi.

The petition was filed by the Kirana Committee of Delhi and the Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchants Association of Chawri Bazar. The traders have argued that demonstrations at Ramlila Maidan affect businesses in some of the capital's busiest commercial areas, obstruct access to roads and disrupt the lives of residents in neighbouring localities.

Traders challenge Ramlila Maidan's designation

Appearing for the petitioners, senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi argued that Ramlila Maidan was unsuitable as a designated protest venue because of its proximity to major commercial centres, including Connaught Place, Chandni Chowk, Chawri Bazar, Khari Baoli and Sadar Bazar.

He challenged the October 11 order issued by Delhi Police designating the ground as a protest site, arguing that the location was surrounded by wholesale and retail markets and densely populated residential areas.

The traders' petition stated that thousands of workers, traders and vendors operate in the surrounding areas. It alleged that the decision to designate the ground had been taken without a publicly available assessment of its impact on businesses and residents.

The petitioners also questioned the absence of safeguards governing the number of demonstrators, the duration of protests, possible damage to property and accountability for losses caused by demonstrations.

They have asked the Supreme Court to quash the October 11 order and direct authorities to conduct a fresh, reasoned assessment after considering the interests of businesses and residents in the surrounding areas.

Protests during festive season cited as cause of losses

The traders initially approached the court after the New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) ordered the closure of Central Park in Connaught Place ahead of a proposed 'Lehra Do Tiranga' march organised by the CJP on October 16, with participation from AISA.

The march was proposed to take place at Connaught Place. The traders had raised concerns over the disruption caused by demonstrations in the commercial district.

The subsequent rally at Ramlila Maidan on November 1, organised by the Congress, further strengthened their objections to the ground being designated as a protest venue.

In their petition, the traders said the demonstrations had taken place during the festive period, when businesses earn a substantial proportion of their annual income.

The Kirana Committee estimated that Delhi records daily business worth approximately ₹500 crore to ₹600 crore, with nearly ₹250 crore at risk each day during the peak trading period between October 2026 and January 2027.

It further claimed that nearly one million establishments, around 10 million livelihoods and approximately 500,000 traders from outside Delhi depended on this commercial activity.

The petitioners said the disruption affected not only business owners but also employees, daily-wage workers, street vendors, hawkers, delivery personnel, drivers and artisans.

They also argued that road closures and restricted access affected people travelling to residential neighbourhoods, hospitals and public transport facilities.

Supreme Court asks protest organisers to be made parties

The latest proceedings follow the Supreme Court's November 3 hearing, when it asked the traders to include the organisations responsible for organising the demonstrations as respondents in the case.

The bench had observed that the court could not properly examine the traders' grievances without hearing the organisations that had called the protests.

Following the direction, the petitioners amended their plea to include the Congress, which organised the November 1 rally, along with the AAP, CJP and AISA.

During the earlier hearing, the bench had also remarked that a designated protest venue could not be occupied indefinitely, pointing out that other groups and sections of society also had the right to demonstrate.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, told the court that the traders' petition should be heard alongside other cases challenging police action and restrictions imposed during the recent Delhi protests.

He argued that the proceedings involved competing fundamental rights: the right to protest on one hand and the rights of traders, workers and residents on the other.

The bench agreed to consider the matters together.

Traders clarify they are not seeking a ban on protests

The petitioners have maintained that they are not seeking to prevent peaceful demonstrations or undermine the constitutional right to protest.

Instead, they have sought a regulatory framework governing the location, duration and scale of protests, along with arrangements for traffic management and uninterrupted access to markets, residential areas, hospitals and public transport.

They have also called for preventive planning and enforcement of the law in cases involving violence or vandalism. However, they clarified that unlawful acts by individuals should not be attributed to peaceful demonstrators as a whole.

The dispute comes after Delhi Police, acting on recommendations from a Union Home Ministry committee, denotified Jantar Mantar as a designated protest venue and identified Ramlila Maidan, Burari Ground and CBD Ground in East Delhi as alternative locations.

The Supreme Court's proceedings will now examine the competing claims of protest organisers and traders, with the amended petition bringing the political parties and organisations behind the demonstrations directly into the case.