The Supreme Court on Thursday ruled that an unwed mother has a better prima facie claim to the custody of her minor child, making it clear that the absence of marriage does not take away a mother's preferential position in custody matters.
The ruling came in a case involving a four-year-old boy whose German mother, based in Singapore, sought his custody from his Indian father, a lawyer. A bench of Justices N Kotiswar Singh and NV Anjaria directed the father to hand over the child's interim custody to the mother, observing that his welfare would be better served by moving to Singapore.
“In the case of a child born to unwed parents, the mother has a better prima facie claim of custody,” the bench said.
Child's welfare takes priority
The court noted that both parents had the ability to look after the child and were emotionally invested in his upbringing. However, it found the mother's proposed arrangements more practical and beneficial, particularly in terms of education and the time she could devote to him.
The mother, who works as vice-president of a video platform, submitted documents showing that her employer permitted work from home and allowed flexibility in her schedule. She had also initiated the process of securing admission for the boy at a prominent school in Singapore and identified alternative institutions.
The father, meanwhile, runs a law firm with around 53 associates and practises across several cities. The bench expressed concern that his professional commitments could leave him dependent on relatives and nannies for much of the child's daily care.
“We are well aware of the limited time a busy lawyer can spare for family members. In the present case, the family member is not an adult, but a small child of four years who is very energetic... who will require much more personal attention,” the court observed.
Schooling and stability key considerations
The court also relied on a NIMHANS assessment, which found that the child had been out of formal schooling for around four months. The report recommended that he return to classes at the earliest, noting that the lack of routine and uncertainty were affecting his behaviour.
Rejecting the father's argument that moving to Singapore would disrupt the boy's surroundings, the bench pointed out that he had already lived in Delhi, Goa, Kolkata and Germany. It said stability depended more on the people, affection and routines surrounding a child than on geographical location.
The court clarified that a mother's preferential claim did not rule out the father's rights. It also directed the mother to obtain a mirror order from a Singapore court within three weeks and deposit Rs 1 crore before taking the child abroad.
The father will have at least 20 minutes of daily video calls, visitation rights in Singapore and custody during the child's visits to India. The mother must also bring him to India during school vacations lasting more than seven days.
The bench clarified that its ruling concerned only interim custody. The Delhi Family Court will independently decide the question of permanent custody.