Delhi HC quashes Pinaki Misra case, noting context and lack of independent witnesses | X 
Legal

Delhi HC quashes Pinaki Misra defamation case over ‘crook’ remark against lawyer

Former BJD MP Pinaki Misra wins relief in Delhi HC over lawyer's defamation complaint

The Delhi High Court has quashed criminal defamation proceedings against Senior Advocate and former Biju Janata Dal (BJD) Member of Parliament Pinaki Misra over a reported remark describing a lawyer as a “crook”, holding that the complainant failed to establish that the statement had lowered his reputation in the eyes of others.

In an order passed on November 17, Justice Sachin Datta set aside the summoning order issued by a trial court in April 2019 and quashed the complaint filed by advocate Siddhartha Singh.

The court observed that the trial court had not considered the context in which the alleged remark was made or the fact that the Bar Council of Delhi had dismissed Singh's professional misconduct complaint.

“It is also noticed that the impugned order does not consider the context in which the words were allegedly used by the petitioner and the dismissal of the complaint by the Bar Council of Delhi,” the High Court said.

Complainant failed to establish reputational damage

Justice Datta noted that Singh had examined only himself as a witness before the trial court. He had neither named nor examined any person who had read the newspaper report or whose opinion of him had allegedly been affected by the remark.

The court found that the complaint lacked material to demonstrate that the alleged imputation had lowered Singh's reputation in the estimation of others, a requirement under the law governing criminal defamation.

The proceedings stemmed from a complaint under Section 500 of the Indian Penal Code, following a summoning order issued by the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate-I at the Rouse Avenue Courts in April 2019.

The High Court allowed Misra's plea under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which empowers courts to exercise inherent jurisdiction to prevent abuse of the process of law and secure the ends of justice.

Dispute originated in Bar Council complaint

The controversy began in 2018, when Singh approached the Bar Council of Delhi alleging professional misconduct against Misra over an alleged conflict of interest.

At the time, Misra was a Lok Sabha MP and chairperson of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Urban Development. Singh had objected to Misra appearing for power distribution companies before the National Green Tribunal, claiming that the parliamentary committee chaired by him had made adverse recommendations against those companies.

An August 2018 report published by The Economic Times covered Singh's complaint before the Bar Council. The report quoted Misra as allegedly describing Singh as a “crook”.

Singh subsequently sent a legal notice to Misra, seeking an unconditional apology, before filing the criminal defamation complaint.

The Bar Council of Delhi dismissed Singh's professional misconduct complaint in November 2018.

Connected defamation case had already been quashed

The High Court also took note of a connected criminal defamation case arising from a report published on Dailyhunt, which had been quashed in August 2026.

In that matter, Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma had set aside the summoning order after finding insufficient material to establish that the alleged remarks had harmed Singh's reputation. The court had also noted the absence of independent witnesses and the lack of evidence from anyone associated with the publication.

The November 17 order in the Economic Times-related case followed the same controversy and considered the context of the alleged remark, the complainant's evidence and the Bar Council's decision.

Lawyers appearing in the matter

Senior Advocate Rebecca M John, along with advocate Anushka Baruah, appeared for Pinaki Misra.

Additional Public Prosecutor Aashneet Singh represented the State.

With the latest order, the Delhi High Court has set aside the April 2019 summoning order and quashed the criminal defamation complaint against Misra.