Delhi HC says Amrit Wilson was denied opportunity to answer OCI cancellation allegations | File Image 
Legal

Delhi HC directs fresh notice in Amrit Wilson OCI case, says Centre failed to specify allegations

Amrit Wilson gets fresh chance to respond as Delhi HC flags natural justice violations

The Delhi High Court has directed the Centre to issue a fresh show cause notice to UK-based author and journalist Amrit Wilson over the cancellation of her Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card, after finding that the original notice and cancellation order did not spell out the alleged anti-India activities attributed to her.

Justice Amit Mahajan held that the proceedings had failed to comply with the principles of natural justice, as Wilson was not given sufficient details of the allegations to enable her to respond effectively.

The court directed the authorities to issue a fresh notice within one week, setting out the specific grounds for cancelling her OCI registration. If the reasons cannot be disclosed in full, the authorities must provide Wilson with the gist of the material, after redacting sensitive information, or allow her to inspect the documents relied upon.

Wilson must submit her reply within one week of receiving the fresh notice. The authorities have been directed to pass a fresh order within two weeks thereafter. In the interim, the existing cancellation order will remain operative for four weeks or until a fresh order is passed, whichever is earlier.

Court says notice failed to disclose specific allegations

The court was hearing Wilson's petition challenging the March 17, 2023, order cancelling her OCI card under Section 7D(e) of the Citizenship Act, 1955.

The cancellation followed a show cause notice issued in November 2022, which alleged that Wilson was engaged in “detrimental propaganda against the Indian government” and had undertaken activities allegedly inimical to India's sovereignty and integrity, security and public interest.

The notice asked her to explain within 15 days why her OCI card should not be cancelled.

Wilson denied involvement in any anti-India activities in her reply. She also pointed out that the notice did not identify specific incidents and sought disclosure of the material on which the allegations were based, so she could present her case effectively.

However, the authorities did not communicate with her for the next three months before cancelling her OCI registration on March 17, 2023.

Before the High Court, Wilson's counsel argued that the Centre had not disclosed the specific incidents forming the basis of the cancellation. The respondents had also failed to explain the reasons in their counter-affidavit before the court, claiming that the material could only be placed before it in a sealed cover.

The court found that neither the show cause notice nor the cancellation order contained details of the alleged anti-India activities.

“A perusal of the SCN and the impugned order indicates that the same is bereft of any specific details of Anti-India activities in which the petitioner was involved, thus, providing no opportunity to the petitioner to provide an explanation in respect of the same,” Justice Mahajan observed.

The court reiterated that a show cause notice must clearly identify the case a person is required to answer. It also noted that the counter-affidavit did not provide specific reasons that would enable Wilson to submit an appropriate response.

OCI rights cannot be withdrawn without opportunity to respond

The High Court observed that Wilson's rights under Section 7B of the Citizenship Act could not be taken away without giving her an appropriate opportunity to respond to the allegations.

It therefore directed the authorities to provide the specific reasons for the proposed cancellation in the fresh notice. Where disclosure of the complete material is not possible, the petitioner must receive its gist with sensitive portions redacted, or be allowed to inspect the material that led to the cancellation.

The court's directions provide Wilson another opportunity to answer the allegations, while leaving the cancellation order temporarily in force pending the fresh proceedings.

Wilson's background and OCI status

Wilson was born in India and lived in the country until 1961, when she moved to the United Kingdom for higher studies. She later settled in the UK and worked as a writer, journalist and social activist.

She surrendered her Indian passport and acquired British citizenship in 2009. Wilson was issued a Person of Indian Origin (PIO) card in 2014 and subsequently received an OCI card on December 20, 2017.

The authorities issued the show cause notice in November 2022, alleging that her activities were detrimental to the Indian government and against the country's sovereignty, integrity, security and public interest. The cancellation order followed in March 2023.

The High Court's latest directions concern the adequacy of the notice and the opportunity afforded to Wilson to respond. The court has not, through these directions, determined the merits of the underlying allegations.