The Delhi High Court on Wednesday directed the Central Government to examine allegations of objectionable content targeting lawyers on social media accounts linked to Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Manasvi Vashistha and another police official, and take appropriate steps to remove the material, if necessary.
A division bench comprising Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma was hearing a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by advocate Karan Bir Singh. The petition seeks action against Vashistha and other Delhi Police personnel over alleged threats, intimidation and derogatory remarks against lawyers amid the recent dispute between police officers and advocates.
The immediate request before the court concerned the removal of allegedly objectionable videos posted on the Facebook and Instagram accounts of the two police officials.
The Centre's counsel told the court that disciplinary proceedings had already been initiated against Vashistha, who was suspended on November 2. A chargesheet has also been submitted to the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA), which is expected to consider and approve it within a reasonable period.
The Centre further said it would examine the social media material if the petitioner provided copies of the relevant posts and videos. It assured the court that appropriate steps would be taken to remove objectionable content, if warranted.
The bench consequently allowed Singh to submit the material to the Centre's counsel within 48 hours for examination and possible action. The court also permitted the respondents to file their counter-affidavit within four weeks, with the petitioner being allowed two weeks thereafter to submit a rejoinder. The Centre's counsel said a status report would be filed within four weeks.
Allegations against police officials
The petition refers to videos allegedly showing Vashistha making threatening and derogatory remarks against advocates. These include statements suggesting that lawyers visiting police stations in groups could face detention and criminal proceedings.
It also cites an alleged video of Sub-Inspector Vishal Yadav threatening to fire an AK-47 rifle at an advocate if the latter laid hands on him.
Singh has argued that, if established, the alleged statements raise serious concerns about criminal intimidation, the misuse of police authority and the safety of lawyers while carrying out their professional duties.
The petition names the Union of India, the Delhi Police Commissioner, the Special Commissioner of Police (Vigilance), ACP Manasvi Vashistha and Sub-Inspector Vishal Yadav as respondents.
It seeks directions to the authorities to protect the safety, dignity and professional independence of advocates. It also asks for the removal of specifically identified social media videos and publications containing alleged unlawful threats, while ensuring that the original electronic evidence is preserved.
Other reliefs sought include an independent, time-bound inquiry into the alleged misconduct of the police personnel and criminal as well as departmental proceedings wherever warranted.
The plea further argues that the participation of serving police personnel in the demonstration should be examined under the Police Forces (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1966, and the applicable service and conduct rules.
While acknowledging that Vashistha has reportedly been suspended, the petitioner maintains that the action does not address the wider allegations involving other police officials, alleged criminal intimidation or the need for institutional safeguards.
Background to the police-lawyers dispute
The petition follows a confrontation between Delhi Police personnel and lawyers over the handling of an assault case involving advocate Lalit Bansal at Shahdara police station.
Lawyers alleged that Vashistha and the station's then Station House Officer, Arun Kumar, threatened them when they visited the police station in connection with the case. The allegations triggered protests and an indefinite strike by lawyers across several district courts in Delhi, who demanded action against the officers.
Vashistha and Arun Kumar were subsequently transferred amid the dispute.
The police-lawyers confrontation was followed by a protest by serving police personnel outside the Delhi Police headquarters. On November 2, Vashistha joined around 100 personnel who gathered outside Gate No. 1 of the headquarters, seeking a meeting with Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar over the developments at Shahdara police station.
Vashistha was subsequently placed under suspension for alleged violation of discipline. The PIL argues that the suspension alone is insufficient to address the allegations and seeks wider accountability and safeguards for advocates.