Abhishek Banerjee must explain remarks against judiciary within 15 days, says Calcutta HC | File Image 
Legal

Calcutta HC initiates criminal contempt proceedings against Abhishek Banerjee over judge remarks

Abhishek Banerjee gets 15 days to explain remarks alleging BJP influence over a Calcutta HC judge

The Calcutta High Court on Tuesday initiated criminal contempt proceedings against Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee over remarks questioning the impartiality of the judiciary and alleging that the judge hearing his case was acting under political pressure from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).

Justice Krishna Rao directed that a show-cause notice be issued to Banerjee, asking him to explain within 15 days why he should not be punished for criminal contempt. The Court took note of the transcript of his remarks in a live interview and a Facebook post dated November 7, observing that the statements prima facie interfered with the administration of justice.

The development came while Banerjee's plea challenging the downgrade of his security cover from Z+ to X category was before the High Court. In a separate direction, Justice Rao asked the West Bengal government's Department of Home and Hill Affairs to convene a security review committee meeting within two weeks to reconsider the TMC MP's request for enhancement of his protection to the Z+ category.

The matter has been listed for further hearing on December 8.

Court takes exception to remarks against judiciary

The controversy came to the fore during the November 12 hearing, when Additional Advocate General Billwadal Bhattacharyya, appearing for the West Bengal government, brought Banerjee's comments in a live interview to the Court's attention.

Banerjee had allegedly accused Justice Rao of deliberately not hearing his urgent security plea before the High Court's annual vacation because of political pressure. He reportedly said that his petition was listed as item number 16 on the last working day before the vacation, but the judge took up only 15 matters before rising without hearing his case.

The TMC MP also accused a section of the judiciary of being aligned with the BJP and acting against the Constitution.

"There are many good judges who have not sold their spine, those who are working really hard to protect the Constitution. But I have no hesitation to say that one class has been completely sold to the BJP," he reportedly said.

Bhattacharyya argued that the comments cast aspersions on the judiciary and could prejudice the pending proceedings, amounting to criminal contempt of court. Banerjee's counsel, however, attributed the remarks to his client's frustration over repeated threats to his life and family. He submitted that the TMC MP had faced several attacks and was being denied adequate protection.

Justice Rao had questioned the allegations against the judiciary and rebuked the counsel over the statements.

"Ask your client for a list of judges with the BJP and TMC party," the judge remarked during the November 12 hearing.

On Tuesday, the Court examined the transcript of Banerjee's remarks and his November 7 Facebook post before directing that a show-cause notice be issued. The proceedings will require Banerjee to explain his position within 15 days.

Banerjee challenges downgrade of Z+ security cover

Banerjee had approached the High Court challenging the West Bengal government's decision to downgrade his security cover from Z+ to X category following the 2026 Assembly elections.

The TMC MP alleged that the decision was politically motivated and was taken without an independent assessment of his threat perception after the BJP came to power in the state. He told the Court that his Z+ security cover had been reaffirmed as recently as 2024, but was subsequently withdrawn.

Banerjee further claimed that the reduction in protection left him vulnerable to several attacks, during which stones, shoes and other objects were allegedly hurled at him. His plea sought restoration of the earlier security arrangement and production of the records on the basis of which the downgrade was ordered.

The State government opposed the petition, arguing that security arrangements were subject to periodic review under established protocols and could not be claimed as a matter of right. It submitted that Banerjee already had three personal security officers (PSOs) protecting him in shifts. It also pointed out that his residence was covered by the Z+ security arrangement provided to former Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, who lives there.

Additional Solicitor General Dhiraj Kumar Trivedi, appearing for the Centre, submitted that the authorities were not required to disclose the reasons for reducing an individual's security cover.

During an earlier hearing on October 6, Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, representing Banerjee, had argued that security protection could not be downgraded without prior notice or consultation with the person concerned. He maintained that an assessment of the individual's threat perception was essential before any decision to reduce the security cover could be taken.

High Court orders fresh security review

While dealing with the security petition, Justice Rao directed the West Bengal government's Home and Hill Affairs Department to convene a review committee meeting within two weeks to reconsider Banerjee's request for enhanced protection.

The committee has been asked to examine the incidents reported by Banerjee and reassess whether his security cover should be upgraded to the Z+ category.

The direction comes alongside the separate criminal contempt proceedings arising from the TMC MP's remarks about the judiciary. The Court is scheduled to hear the matter again on December 8.